On an exposed fastener metal roof, the screws are the part that wears out first, and it is the rubber washer under each screw head that fails. We install 5/16-inch ZXL screws instead of the usual 1/4-inch screws because the ZXL has a cap that covers the washer and shields it from the sun. Standard screws typically need replacing every 12 to 15 years. ZXL screws should last longer, though they may still need replacing around 20 years.
Below we explain how exposed fastener roofs are held down, why the washers fail, what makes a ZXL screw different, and what it means for the long-term cost of your roof.
Watch: why Starway Roof Systems uses 5/16-inch ZXL screws instead of 1/4-inch screws.
Exposed fastener panels, sometimes called screw-down panels, are fastened with screws driven straight through the face of the metal into the wood or steel underneath. Depending on the size of the roof, that can be hundreds or thousands of screws.
Each screw has a rubber washer under its head. When the screw is driven, the washer squeezes against the panel and seals the hole. That washer is what keeps water out at every one of those screws.
Exposed fastener panels cost less than standing seam and go on faster, which is why they are popular on homes, barns and garages around Central PA. The tradeoff is those washers.
Rubber that sits in direct sun for years dries out, hardens and cracks. Once the washer can no longer press tight against the panel, water can follow the screw into the roof.
Metal expands as it heats up and shrinks as it cools, and Central PA can swing a long way between a cold night and a sunny afternoon. Each swing works the panels against the screws, which can slowly loosen them and wear the washers.
Worn screws do not always mean you need a new roof. On many roofs, the screws can be replaced. Replacing them typically costs $3,500 to $12,000, depending on the size and steepness of the roof.
If water drips inside on dry, cool mornings instead, it is more likely condensation than a leak. Our post on metal roof condensation and DripStop explains the difference.
On the standard screw most exposed fastener roofs use, the rubber washer is a separate piece under a 1/4-inch hex head. Its edge sits out from under the head, right where the sun hits it every day.
The ZXL screw has a larger 5/16-inch head with a cap made of a zinc-aluminum alloy that covers the washer. The sun cannot reach the rubber, so it does not dry out and crack as quickly. The manufacturer also says the cap protects the head from red rust.
| Standard 1/4-inch screw | 5/16-inch ZXL screw | |
|---|---|---|
| Head size | 1/4-inch hex head | 5/16-inch hex head |
| Rubber washer | Separate piece under the head, with its edge exposed | Covered by a zinc-aluminum cap |
| Sun on the washer | Every day | Shielded from UV |
| Typical replacement | Every 12 to 15 years | Longer, but may need replacing around 20 years |
Standard screws typically need replacing every 12 to 15 years. ZXL screws should last longer than that, but they may still need replacing around 20 years. No screw on an exposed fastener roof lasts as long as the panels.
Over the life of the roof, that can mean one less round of screw replacement, and fewer years with worn washers on your roof.
If you would rather never replace screws, standing seam metal hides its fasteners under the seams, so there are no washers out in the weather. It costs more up front. On a home under 2,500 square feet in Central PA, exposed fastener metal runs about $10,500 to $41,500 and standing seam about $21,000 to $65,000. Our roof replacement cost guide breaks those ranges down by home size and roof pitch.
Exposed fastener metal with ZXL screws is a good middle ground if you want a metal roof at a lower price and are fine planning for screw replacement down the road. It is also a common choice for barns, garages and other outbuildings. On those, ask about DripStop as well, since uninsulated buildings are where condensation causes the most trouble.
If you are getting quotes for an exposed fastener metal roof, ask which screws are included. Ours use 5/16-inch ZXL screws. If you already have an exposed fastener roof that is 12 or more years old, have the screws checked before a small leak at a screw turns into rotted decking.
To compare exposed fastener and standing seam roofs side by side, see our metal roofs page.
Standard screws on an exposed fastener metal roof typically need replacing every 12 to 15 years, because the rubber washers break down in the sun. ZXL screws should last longer, but they may still need replacing around 20 years.
A ZXL screw is a metal roofing screw with a 5/16-inch head and a zinc-aluminum cap that covers the rubber washer. The cap shields the washer from the sun's UV, so it lasts longer than the washer on a standard screw.
On a standard 1/4-inch screw, the rubber washer is a separate piece whose edge sits out in the sun. On a ZXL screw, the cap covers the washer and protects it from UV, which is the main thing that wears washers out.
Yes. We use 5/16-inch ZXL screws on the exposed fastener metal roofs we install. Standing seam roofs use hidden fasteners, so they have no exposed screws.
Replacing the screws on an exposed fastener metal roof typically costs $3,500 to $12,000 in Central PA, depending on the size and steepness of the roof.
No. Standing seam roofs hide their fasteners under the seams, so there are no exposed washers to wear out and no screws to replace.
Have a question we didn’t cover? Call Starway Roof Systems: (814) 308-0490