4 min read

Fixing a Failed Roof Repair in DuBois, PA: Case Study

Fixing a Failed Roof Repair in DuBois, PA: Case Study
7:58

In November 2026, Starway Roof Systems replaced the roof on a brick ranch home in DuBois, Pennsylvania, after an earlier repair by another contractor failed. The low-slope section of the roof had been covered with rubber, then with metal panels, and both had been coated with sealant to try to stop the leaks. About five years later it was leaking badly again, and there was mold throughout the attic. We tore everything off, rebuilt the roof around the chimney, installed a new Mule-Hide EPDM rubber roof on the low-slope section, and put Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration shingles in Colonial Slate on the rest of the home.

Front of the brick ranch home in DuBois, PA with its new Owens Corning Colonial Slate shingle roof

After: the front of the home with its new roof, November 2026.

Project at a Glance

  • Location: DuBois, PA
  • Completed: November 2026
  • Roof size: About 30 squares (roughly 3,000 square feet): 24 squares of shingles and 6 squares of rubber roofing
  • The problem: A low-slope roof section that kept leaking after an earlier repair, and mold in the attic
  • Removed: The old shingles, the metal panels and the furring strips under them, and the old rubber roof
  • Low-slope section: Mule-Hide .060 EPDM rubber roofing, fully adhered
  • Pitched sections: Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration shingles in Colonial Slate
  • Chimney: New plywood decking beside it and new flashing
  • Ventilation: New ridge vent, and a bathroom vent run out through the roof
  • Time on site: A day and a half

The Problem: A Repair That Did Not Hold

The homeowner had been trying to get this roof fixed for a long time. He had a lot of people out to look at it, and he hired a contractor who did a repair. About five years later, the roof was leaking badly again.

When we inspected the home in August 2026, this is what we found on the low-slope section:

  • Rubber roofing had been put down and coated with sealant to try to stop the leaks.
  • Metal panels had then been installed over it, and those were coated with sealant too.
  • Sealant was packed around the chimney and along the seams where the roof sections meet.
  • Water was still getting in, and there was mold throughout the attic.

Sealant-coated metal panels around the chimney on the DuBois home before the roof replacement

Before: the coated metal panels around the chimney, August 2026.

Close-up of sealant spread over a seam on the old low-slope roof in DuBois, PA

Before: sealant spread over a seam on the old roof.

Why Another Patch Was Not the Answer

This roof had already been patched twice, once with rubber and sealant and once with metal and sealant, and it still leaked. With that many layers on the roof, there was no way to see or fix what was underneath. The only way to know the roof was right was to take every layer off, look at the wood, and build the low-slope section again from the decking up.

What We Did

Tore Everything Off

We removed the old shingles, all of the metal panels and the furring strips under them, and the old rubber roof. That took the roof down to its original board decking, which we re-nailed where it was loose.

Tear-off in progress on the DuBois home showing the original board decking and new underlayment

During: tear-off under way, with the original board decking showing.

Rebuilt the Roof Around the Chimney

The chimney was one of the places the old repair had leaned on sealant. We replaced the decking beside it with new plywood and installed new flashing where the roof meets the brick.

New plywood decking installed beside the brick chimney during the DuBois roof replacement

During: new plywood decking beside the chimney.

Installed a New Rubber Roof on the Low-Slope Section

New cover board was fastened down over the low-slope section, and Mule-Hide .060 EPDM rubber roofing was glued down over it with new seam tape. EPDM is made for low-slope roofs, where shingles are not the right material.

New cover board fastened around the chimney before the EPDM rubber roof was installed

During: new cover board around the chimney, ready for the rubber roof.

New flashing where the brick chimney meets the new EPDM rubber roof in DuBois, PA

After: new flashing where the chimney meets the rubber roof.

Installed New Shingles on the Rest of the Home

Ice and water shield and synthetic underlayment went down first, followed by starter strip, Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration shingles in Colonial Slate, and Owens Corning ProEdge hip and ridge caps. New drip edge and two new pipe boots went on as well.

New EPDM rubber roof meeting the new Owens Corning Colonial Slate shingles on the DuBois home

After: the new rubber roof where it meets the new shingles.

Added Ridge Vent and a Roof Vent

We installed ridge vent along the peaks so heat and moisture can leave the attic, and we ran a bathroom vent out through the roof with a new roof vent.

New ridge vent along the peak of the Colonial Slate shingle roof in DuBois, PA

After: the new ridge vent along the peak.

New roof vent for a bathroom fan on the Colonial Slate shingle roof

After: the new roof vent.

How Long It Took

We inspected the roof on August 14, 2026, and the homeowner signed the proposal on September 1. Work started on Friday, November 13, 2026, and the whole job took a day and a half.

The Result

The home has a new rubber roof on the low-slope section, new shingles everywhere else, and new flashing around the chimney. The layers of sealant, metal and old rubber are gone. The homeowner was really happy with how it turned out.

FAQs About This Project

Can sealant fix a leaking low-slope roof?

On this DuBois home it did not. An earlier repair relied on sealant over the old rubber roof, then on metal panels with more sealant, and about five years later the roof was leaking badly again. We removed all of it and installed a new EPDM rubber roof.

What is EPDM rubber roofing?

EPDM is a rubber membrane used on flat and low-slope roof sections. On this home we installed Mule-Hide .060 EPDM, glued down over the low-slope section with new seam tape.

Can one house have both shingles and a rubber roof?

Yes. This home has Owens Corning shingles on the pitched sections and EPDM rubber on the low-slope section, tied together where the two meet.

How long did this roof replacement take?

A day and a half. That covered tearing off the old shingles, the metal panels and the old rubber roof, rebuilding around the chimney, and installing the new shingles and rubber roof.

Does Starway Roof Systems work in DuBois?

Yes. Starway Roof Systems serves DuBois, Clearfield and Treasure Lake.

Dealing With a Roof Leak That Keeps Coming Back in the DuBois Area?

If your roof has been repaired and is leaking again, we can take a look and walk you through your options. See our roofing services in DuBois, or learn more about roof repair, roof replacement, flat and low-slope roofs and shingle roofs.

You can also read what other customers say in our customer reviews.

Request your free inspection today.

Call Starway Roof Systems: (814) 308-0490

Roof Replacement in Treasure Lake, DuBois, PA: Case Study

1 min read

Roof Replacement in Treasure Lake, DuBois, PA: Case Study

In August 2026, Starway Roof Systems replaced a leaking roof that was more than 20 years old on a two-story home in Treasure Lake, in DuBois,...

Read More
What’s The Average Roof Inspection Cost?

1 min read

What’s The Average Roof Inspection Cost?

In the hustle and bustle of daily life, it’s easy to overlook the health of your roof. Yet, ensuring your roof is in good condition is paramount to...

Read More
How Long Does a Roof Last? (On Average)

1 min read

How Long Does a Roof Last? (On Average)

A roof is one of the most crucial elements of a home, providing shelter and protection from the elements. However, like all things, roofs have a...

Read More